Each month I try to participate in the #MovieMondayChallenge. This month’s theme is Halloween movies and since I have a few Harry Potter fans, I knew that would be my selection. Tasha has been excited to be able to bake in our new kitchen. She and I tossed around a few projects ideas and foods from the books and movies and decided to make Pumpkin Pasties with Butterbeer Frosting.
Flaky Buttery Gluten Free Pie Crust
Tasha spent some time making pies with both of her grandmother’s this summer. Since she seems to do best gluten-free, we wanted to make our Pumpkin Pasties gluten-free. Pasties are basically hand pies, pie crust pockets of goodness.
Over the years I’ve tried several different gluten-free pie crusts, they have all been lacking. But, we decided to give this recipe from Comfortably Domestic a try.
Guess what, IronFish didn’t even know our Pumpkin Pasties were gluten-free!

We did make a few little changes from the original recipe… I only had salted butter on hand, so I didn’t add salt. We also added a tablespoon of sugar.
Tasha started by cutting 8 tablespoons of salted butter into 2 cups of gluten-free all-purpose flour.

Then, she mixed in the beaten egg. Using her hands to mix, she worked in the ice water, one tablespoon at a time (about 6-8).

Once the dough all came together in a ball, we were ready to go.

We dusted some more gluten-free flour over a silicone mat and rolled out half of the dough, refrigerating the rest.

We originally planned on a traditional hand pie or pastie half circle, but when we pulled out the rolling pin the pumpkin cookie cutter was waiting to be used!
Pumpkin Filling
Mix together:
- 1 cup pumpkin puree
- 1/4 cup soft cream cheese
- 2 tablespoons sugar
- 2 tablespoons brown sugar
- 2 tablespoons Pumpkin Pie Spice
- pinch of salt
- 1 egg yolk (reserve the white for egg wash later)
- 1/2 teaspoon vanilla extract

We threw it all in and mixed it up.

Next, we added a scoop on top of each of our pumpkins.

Tasha wet the edges of each pumpkin with a bit of the ice water and added a second pumpkin pie crust cut out on top.
After crimping the edges closed, we brushed each Pumpkin Pastie with egg wash (watered down egg white).

Bake for 15-20 minutes at 425.
Butterbeer Frosting
Unfortunately, my sous chef left to hang out with her friends while the Pumpkin Pasties cooled. Since I made the frosting up without her, I forgot to take pictures. But, it starts with a basic buttercream frosting.
To make the frosting melt 1/4 cup of butter. Beat in powdered sugar (I have a 1/4 scoop, I add a scoop at a time until it’s crumbly, probably about 2 cups total).
For buttercream frosting, I would then start adding milk or water until I had the consistency I was going for. But, for this frosting, I used Salted Caramel Coffee Creamer!
Continue to blend and add the coffee creamer until the frosting is runny.
Melt 1/4 cup butterscotch chips in the microwave for 30 seconds at a time. Once melted, add into the frosting. As the butterscotch cools it will stiffen the frosting which is why I made it a bit runny initially.
Drizzle over the Pumpkin Pasties!

Enjoy Gluten-Free Pumpkin Pasties with Butterbeer Frosting while watching your favorite Harry Potter movie!

[mpprecipe-recipe:4]
Movie Monday
On the last Monday of each month, a group of bloggers participates in a #MovieMondayChallenge, hosted by C’mon Get Crafty! We decide on a topic, genre, or specific movie to use for inspiration and everyone gets free reign to create something wonderful!
This month’s challenge was. . . . HALLOWEEN!!!! Everyone was allowed to choose their own favorite Halloween-themed film for this challenge.
Now let’s see what everyone else was inspired to create for this month’s #MovieMondayChallenge!! If you’d like to join our Facebook group, you can request an invite here.
INLINKZ:
Pin and Share
As always, feel free!


Looks great, the filling sounds delicious!
These look delicious and your daughter seemed to enjoy herself in the kitchen.
She really does, she’s made these a second time already!
Well, I am super excited to try to make these! We are big Potterheads in our household, so my husband will only be grateful for my efforts, lol.
They went fast and we had to make a second batch!
What a fun idea to make the dough into pumpkin shapes. The pumpkin filling and the butterbeer frosting sounds like a delicious combination. Stopping by from the #HomeMattersParty linky to check out your recipe.
Those pumpkin pasties look adorable, and yummy. And the butterbeer frosting sounds heavenly. I know my tween girls will love making these. Thanks!
The frosting really was heavenly!
How fun!! My daughter had a Harry Potter themed birthday party this year. She would have loved to have made these. #HomeMattersParty
You had me at the mention of Harry Potter. I have tried the butter beer at Universal and love it. I’m definitely giving these a try this weekend. #HomeMattersParty
How cute are these!!! Love that your daughter made them too and she looks like a true pro! What awesome Halloween treats!!
Thanks, I’m enjoying her learning!
What a fun recipe! I love that your daughter was able to demonstrate some of the steps. It seems like a good project for a sleepover/movie party.
She’s been making them like crazy with her friends!
Very creative!! #dreamteam
Sounds like a yummy recipe! Your daughter did a great job! Thank you for sharing on Merry Monday! Hope to see ya next week!
Kim
NICE POST
No way! This sounds SO good, and I’m a sucker for anything Harry Potter. 🙂 Pinning this!
#embracingchangelinky
My grown kids would love these – they grew up with Harry Potter! xx
How fun are these! I love Harry Potter foods! Thanks for sharing with Thursday Favorite Things! We are so happy you joined us! Angelina @ Petite Haus
Yum! These look fantastic and are so fitting for October. The butterbeer topping sounds like the perfect twist to these little pockets. Something to try for the lead up to Halloween 🎃 Thanks for joining us for the #Dreamteam.